How to Make Your Thinning, Over-Plucked Aging Eyebrows Look Lush and Full

How to Make Your Thinning, Over-Plucked Aging Eyebrows Look Lush and Full

Here’s how you can fill in your sparse eyebrows to look natural and full even if they’re over plucked or thinning because of aging. Step-by-step how to with tons of tips and tutorials to watch.

This post may contain affiliate links. For more information, see my disclosures here.

Have you ever added a new piece of furniture only to realize that now you need to redecorate the entire house? I felt that way after my “up your eyeshadow game” project this fall. After immersing myself in YouTube videos to learn some techniques to enhance my increasingly hooded eyelids, I tried some of the techniques on my own eyes and was thrilled with the results. Until I took some selfies to document my new fantastic look.

All I could see in the photos were my eyebrows. Or rather, I couldn’t see my eyebrows in the photos! Years of over-plucking and waxing, combined with the natural effects of aging, had turned my eyebrows into thin, barely-visible marks above my eyes, instead of the thick, lush, brows I wanted to frame my face.

Before: Very thin and sparse brows

My “after” photo turned into a “before” photo and I immediately started a new beauty project: making over my eyebrows to try to undo the damage I inflicted on my brows during my years of abuse.

Step 1: DetermineYour Best Brow Shape

First, I stopped plucking and waxing my brows for a few months until I felt my brows had grown in as much as they were going to. Then I took myself over to The Perfect Brows by Leza, a local brow salon with great Yelp reviews, to see what they could do for me.

It turns out they could do quite a lot! My stylist, Lynnita, greeted me and took me over to her chair to talk about my brow goals. After I told her that I wanted to see what I could do to enhance and fill in my brows, she took out a brow pencil and outlined my perfect brow shape so we could see how much work was needed to get my brows in great shape.

I am sharing this wildly unflattering photo with you so you can learn from my experiences. You’re welcome! Here we see the pencil outline of where my brows should be compared to where my brows actually are. We have a lot of work ahead of us

Lynnita taught me to find my perfect brow shape. Hold an index card vertically from the bridge of your nose to find where your brow should begin and then angle the index card diagonally to find where your brow should end. The arch of your brow should be over the spot where your iris meets the white of your eye.

Ideal Brow Placement

Step 2: Tint Your Brows so All Your Brow Hairs Show Up

After Lynnita drew in my aspirational brow shape, she told me that I actually had a good many small and white hairs that we could enhance by tinting my brows. So I went for it! She applied a vegetable-based dye to my brows and I sat for about 10 minutes while the brow took effect. It actually stung a little bit which surprised me but it wasn’t anything I couldn’t handle.

Step 3: Fill In with Brow Powder as Needed

Once my brows were tinted, Lynnita gave me a light and painless(!) brow wax to tidy up any stray hairs and then spent a long time showing me how to use brow powder and a soft brush to fill in any sparse areas. Here I am with one eye complete – check out the difference!

One brow done and one to go. The difference is already amazing.

I was thrilled with my results. Check out my after shot!

I love this so much! What a difference.

Can You Really Permanently Improve Your Eyebrows?

After my makeover, Lynnita and I discussed some ways I could fill in my brows more permanently. She told me to start using castor oil on my eyebrows every night to encourage new hair growth. I’ve been using this organic castor oil on my brows every night and I swear I already see improvements.

Lynitta also told me I was a great candidate for microblading, a technique where thin, individual hairs are drawn on your brows using a permanent ink deposited by a microblade pen. It’s similar to tattooing on new brows but much more subtle and realistic. It’s pricey and time-consuming but the before and after pictures I saw were amazing. I will definitely consider this in the future.

Maintaining Your Eyebrows

Maintaining my new look has been super-easy. Before I put on my eye makeup, I use a thin, fine brush to swipe on a bit of brow powder below my brows and then brush it in with a clean spoolie. Next, I swipe a bit of the power on top of my brow line and brush that in as well. Finally, I add a line of concealer just below my brows to make a crisp line. The whole thing takes less than a minute.

I’m thrilled with the result and committed to regular upkeep. Brow tinting only lasts around 6 weeks because eyebrow hairs have a very short growth cycle so I’ll need to go back for regular appointments every couple of months. And I’m definitely considering microblading because then I’ll only need to focus on keeping my brows nicely shaped.

Helpful Videos!

I didn’t do a video of my eyebrow makeover (next time!) so here’s a quick rundown of some helpful videos that go into more detail.

Pin on Pinterest Now!

Get the Newsletter!

Sign up for Midlife Rambler's weekly e-mail and receive exclusive content not available on the website. Plus, you'll get access to the Midlife Rambler Resource Library with tons of e-books and more to help you live your best life!

We won't send you spam. Unsubscribe at any time. Powered by ConvertKit


  1. Stacy Sutton
    January 30, 2017 / 4:34 pm

    I’ve also started tinting my brows, down at The Brow Nook at Edgewood. Have thought about Microblading – if you do it, let me know how it goes!

  2. Christina H.
    February 1, 2017 / 12:43 pm

    Cool, you really gave me some hope for my brows. They have disappeared over the years. I will be talking to my stylist soon to see what she can do for me. Yours look wonderful, very pretty!

    • Katy
      February 1, 2017 / 1:21 pm

      Thanks so much! I had lost hope too so I was thrilled to find that there is stuff I can do. Next up – microblading!

  3. beth
    April 30, 2017 / 11:05 pm

    What is a spoolie?

    • Katy
      May 1, 2017 / 3:53 pm

      Thanks for asking! A spoolie is like a mascara wand except it doesn’t have any product on it. So you can use it to apply powder that comes in a separate container or just to brush through your brows and lashes to separate them.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *